Blog

If you're thinking about staying in your home as you age, you've probably wondered about making it more accessible. Two popular options keep coming up: residential elevators and stair lifts. But which one makes sense for your situation?

Honestly, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. It really comes down to your specific needs, budget, and how long you're planning to stay put. Let’s walk through what we have learned.

Stair Lifts: The Quick Fix That Works

A stair lift is a motorized seat that rides up and down a rail attached to your staircase. You sit down, push a button, and up you go.

The good stuff:

• They're way less expensive than elevators
• Installation is usually done in a few days
• Your contractor isn't tearing up your house
• Perfect if you can still get around pretty well, but stairs are becoming a problem

The not-so-good stuff:

• They only cover one staircase. If your home has multiple levels, you’ll likely need a separate lift for each one, which can add up quickly.
• Aesthetically? Let’s just say they prioritize function over fashion.
• Practicality can be a challenge—things like carrying laundry, groceries, or even your morning coffee can be tricky.
• While stair lifts work great for mild to moderate mobility issues, they may not be a forever fix.

Home Elevators: The Long-Term Investment

A residential elevator is a small lift system built right into your house. You've got options—hydraulic, traction, or pneumatic versions.

Why people love them:

• Wheelchair accessible from day one
• Works great for multi-story homes
• You can easily carry stuff with you (groceries, laundry, that heavy vacuum cleaner)
• They can look really nice when properly installed
• Adds real value to your home
• Grows with you as your needs change

The reality check:

• They're more expensive than stair lifts
• Installation takes time and planning
• Depending on your house, you might need some construction work
• Regular maintenance is a must

Let's Talk Real Numbers

Budget: Stair lifts win hands down. If you need something now and don't have elevator money, a stair lift gets the job done.

Time: Stair lifts again. A few days versus potentially weeks of construction? Easy choice if you're in a hurry.

Actually using it: This is where elevators shine. If you're in a wheelchair or using a walker, a stair lift may not cut it. Even if you're mobile now, an elevator gives you room to grow.

Space: Chair lifts barely take up any room. Elevators need somewhere to go, though the newer pneumatic ones are surprisingly compact.

So What Should You Choose?

Go with a stair lift if:

• You need help now and don't want to wait
• Budget is tight
• You're dealing with a temporary situation (recovering from surgery, for example)
• You live in a simple two-story house
• Major construction isn't realistic for your situation

Consider an elevator if:

• You're planning to stay in this house for the long haul
• Someone in your family uses mobility aids
• You want something that'll work no matter how your needs change
• You've got a multi-level house
• You don't mind the investment for the convenience and peace of mind